Technology shaped Mission to Mission
shaped Technology: Jacques Ellul’s
reflection
Intro:
Today more than ever we have crisis in mission and crisis in
contexts. Kosoko Koyama said crisis is both danger and opportunity for us in
mission. It is danger because we are not
sure about the results and people have not yet accepted new ventures. It is an
opportunity because it opens up new ways, methods and relations to witness
Christ to all. Recently in mission opportunities people are asked to use all
means and methods available so that we can reach out and share the gospel to
all people. Some have emphasised to accept the context as it is and use the
available cultural means in every possible ways. But uncritical use of such
culture and means has not produced expected results rather in some contexts has
been counterproductive. So inculturation in terms of means and methods that are
evolving in the modern contexts need a creative and critical understanding so
that when we use one becomes sensitive to the ways of rebuilding the humanity
and restoring lives and thus bring life affirming Gospel to all.
Let me go back to crisis in context and in mission again. I
wish to start with a few examples. First recently the removal of Bibles from
the hotels, (though the main reason was for multicultural and mutlireligious
respect and so the so call rationalists fought to the end to remove the Bibles)
one of the other reasons in other countries was if people wanted to read
Bibles, there are many other means and technologies available to them and so
there is no need to have a printed Bible in the hotel rooms. There is a scarcity of Bibles in printed
format while access online and elsewhere it is available.
In one the marriages that I celebrated recently, the
marrying couple requested the best man to read 1 Corinthians 13. It was the
first time for him to read the Bible text and also for many in the rehearsal.
As he read, his tone changed and his face shined and started reading it louder
and louder. At the end of the chapter, he said I never knew such a lovely
passage existed in the Bible. Interestingly there is a need for Biblical
literacy among many who do not have access to reading Bibles. Biblical literacy has implications to knowing
the Christian values which may be available otherwise and also may not be
available to people at all.
Then we have third example or examples that every one of us
would identify with. Recently many video clips were shared in social networks
in which cruel murder or killing of people were explicitly presented
particularly of Christians in Iraq. Those who took video seem just taking them
without any sense of relating to the victim or to the killers. So sad even in some
accidents people have not taken some initiative to save the people rather took
video of them. Here comes a question: are we ignoring our basic human values?
Our essence of being a community or being a family or being a Christian has
come under question in the diminishing values with an amoral social networking
and technologies. Are Christian values
and so the Biblical literacy still relevant today?
Recently in many developing countries urban houses have
easier access to fibre optics than clean water. So are we making technology a Babel to be
built?
In such contexts what is our mission? What are the deeper
insight that we can derive from further research into a critical engagement of
technology and also using Ellul’s dialectic approach to this issue? These are
some question that I am trying to ask in this paper. When I read through Ellul I would look like a
bit of hopeless pessimist. But Ellul told that he was not a pessimist.
Mission?
For me, mission means following Jesus in his diverse ways of
doing God’s will in his words, actions and life.
It also includes to heal, to listen (akouow), to empty
oneself (Kenotic), to pray, to liberate, to save,…
What is Technology Shaped Mission?
It means to
accept the fact there is a fascination among missionaries to use all the
available technology as means for increasing the numbers into Christian fold. Technology
is a means to shape the mission in this view. In my articles for Edinburgh 2010, I have
analysed the missionaries use of the kinds of media and technology for mission.
Many of them used technology and means of communication as extension of pulpit.
In my first book how various mission
agencies and worldwide mission institutions have looked at technology and means
of communication in two ways.
-
Accepting the culture of technology and communication as it
is and using them for the mission of the church
- using them as means of communication to provide
information about Christian faith
- taking the audience simply as receivers without taking
their diverse ways of reception or their own questions or their own search for
meanings of life and of God
- Unidirectional view of communication
Technology designs life style, human beings – human beings
changes themselves in order to suit their life in using technology – in a way
human beings serve tech and thus becomes secondary. In this sense technology
shapes life, faith and worldview.
The churches often use the technology and means of
communication as an extension of pulpit.
Second
view is that the churches oten see the media having next
The second
prevailing view is that the churches tend to see the technology as if they have
much impact and effect on people and their communities and have concerns about
moral and ethical concerns of the technology on human beings. This leads to
either neglect or rejection or ignoring the technology, its culture and its
ability to engage or encounter or challenge in their mission and ministry of
the church.
Let me look at the Mission shaped Church Document:
They
recognised social trends in the past three decades. One of their description of
the Western society is Network society. They recognise the importance of new
social structure.
Let me
highlight a few statements of Mission Shaped Church:
1.
The
study recognises the fact that the social and cultural trends have changed for
the past three decades. Such as housing, employment, mobility, family life,
using free time…
2.
The
society became fragmented, people have less free time, people become more
mobile and so on. The statement has taken a moralistic approach to the changes
3.
The
statement then recognises the emergence of a new network society. It gives more
importance to flow than place/space.
Flows of information, images and capital shape the society and also
increase the mobility.
4.
Internet
is seen both an example of network society and a metaphor for understanding it.
It has no centre. No one place. Network of relationships are formed. Of course
they recognise the fact that there are centres of power that control the net.
5.
Network
does not replace neighbourhoods but change them. Sense of community is disconnected to locality
and geography. Information and knowledge have speeded up, shrinking the world
but not with a sense of community. A society connecting and fragmenting at the
same time. Less lasting commitment,
6.
Mission
is to go to the place where the people are, rather than bringing them where the
church is
7.
It
also reflects on consumer culture in which freedom to choose and choices,
progress,
8.
It
highlights the need for repentance, incarnation aspect of mission, allow
churches to be open for variations, retelling of the gospel stories.
This statement recognises the changes in the culture and
context particularly identifying them as networking. But it looks into it as
something that is wrong without going into deeper analysis of the culture that
evolves. Also it takes the culture as it is and as a reality that cannot be
challenged but to engage with the gospel and thus asking the church to consider
exploring various ways of reinterpreting the gospel stories to this context. In
a way this is one of the ways of doing mission but unless we engage a bit more
deeper level of technological interactions with the culture, cultural shaping
of technology we may ignore an important two dimensional aspects of mission
which not only engages with the culture as it is but also creatively and
critically challenges in order to give values for human dignity, rediscover new
forms of human relationship and also
re-emphasise hope and faith in God.
Sociological
reflections on technology
There are different sociological views as well.
Technology is not neutral. Information is not merely
communication – Communication is an act in common – relational, affirms life,
participatory. Technology is to assist life and human relations not the other
way around. Technology is a construct in itself and it in turn constructs
realities for people.
In this context I wish to read Jacques Ellul. It is hard to
read Ellul but it is worth reading a number of times. The basic books are
Technological Society, Humiliation of the Word, Presence of the Kingdom and
Technological bluff.
Who is Ellul?
Jacques Ellul is a French Philosopher and a lay theologian (January 6, 1912 – May 19, 1994). He was born
January 6, 1912 in Bordeaux, France, the only child of Joseph and Martha Ellul.
Jacques' father, Joseph, was born in Malta with British citizenship, but grew
up in Trieste which was then a port city under Austrian rule. Joseph's father
was Italian and his mother was Serbian. He has written 40 books and 800
articles and his writings cover a wide range of areas of sociology, theology,
law and history. His dominant theme is the threat to human freedom and
Christian faith created by modern technology. He read Karl Barth and Karl Marx
and critically engaged with both in his writings.
Conversion to
Christianity
In the
summer prior to commencing university studies Jacques reluctantly relates that
he had a pre-conversion experience. He had completed his secondary school
finals, and was engaged in translating Faust, when "all of a sudden I knew
myself to be in the presence of something so astounding, so overwhelming, that
had entered me to the very core of my being. I jumped on a bicycle and fled. I
thought to myself: 'You have been in the presence of God.' I started to run for
my life from the One who had revealed himself to me. I realized that God had
spoken, but I did not want him to have me. I did not want to be controlled by
another." You can see why he appreciated the story of Jonah, and wrote a
book on the prophet.
A year
later, at age nineteen, Jacques Ellul read Karl Marx's Das Kapital. This was at a time when he was
particularly disturbed at the family's poverty, the social inequities around
him, and the injustice of his father being such a brilliant man but unable to
find work. This was 1931, after the financial collapse of 1929. He appreciated
Marx's dialectic materialism, and later credited Marx with forcing him to study
the Church sociologically.
Three years
later, at age 22, Jacques Ellul relates that he experienced what he called the
"second stage of my conversion." He was reading the Bible in the
eighth chapter of Romans, and "I was converted with a certain
brutality." "I saw a perspective beyond history." When he told
his mother (who had avoided any overt religious influence as a promise to his
father), he said, "I believe in Jesus Christ. I have converted." His
mother replied (without looking up), "I am not surprised. I have been
praying for that every night since you were born." Although Ellul was
reticent to discuss his personal conversion, it is reported that he wrote an
account of such that was not to be published until after his death.
Ellul’s theology
God descends to humanity and joins us where we are. ...the
presence of faith in Jesus Christ alters reality. Whenever the witness
of the Holy Spirit is received and accepted
(hu)man has a freedom and power
which …. Correspond to the freedom and power of the word of God itself.
"The Bible tells us that the Christian is in the world, and that
there he must remain. The Christian has not been created in order to separate
himself from, or live aloof from the world. ...if the Christian is necessarily in the world, he is not of it. This means that his thought,
his life, and his heart are not controlled by the world, and do not depend upon
the world, for they belong to another Master. Thus, since he belongs to another
Master, the Christian has been sent into this world by this Master, and his
communion with his Master remains unbroken, in spite of the 'world' in which he
has to live.
"...the Christian finds that he is not confronted by the material forces of the world but by its spiritual reality. Because he is in communion with Jesus Christ he has to fight not against flesh and blood but against 'the principalities, against the powers, against the world-rulers of this darkness.' At the same time this communion assures him that he does not belong to the world, that he is free from the fatality of the world which is moving towards death, and, as a result of this liberation by grace, he can fight against the spiritual realities of the world."
"...the Christian finds that he is not confronted by the material forces of the world but by its spiritual reality. Because he is in communion with Jesus Christ he has to fight not against flesh and blood but against 'the principalities, against the powers, against the world-rulers of this darkness.' At the same time this communion assures him that he does not belong to the world, that he is free from the fatality of the world which is moving towards death, and, as a result of this liberation by grace, he can fight against the spiritual realities of the world."
Ellul uses dialectic approach as his theological
method. (necessity and freedom)
Technology and Ellul
Technology enslaves by creating an
artificial rational technical mindset and a persuasive necessity! Regarding
technology, instead of it being subservient to humanity, "human beings
have to adapt to it, and accept total change.
Modern technology has become a total phenomenon for
civilization, the defining force of a new social order in which efficiency is
no longer an option but a necessity imposed on all human activity.
What is
technique? He describes it as “the ensemble of practices by which one uses available
resources in order to achieve certain valued ends” (Ellul 18). Technique, as
distinguished from its individual techniques, is the overarching collection of
means in society.
From the
beginning of life humans have used techniques for specific ends. But in the
eighteenth century, the multiplicity and efficiency of these techniques, along
with the establishment of a few necessary social conditions, created a new
phenomenon – the rule of technique over humanity.
“Our modern
worship of technique derives from man’s ancestral worship of the mysterious and
marvelous character of his own handiwork” (Ellul 24). Humans have always used
technique as a means for inventing.
The spread
of Christianity, Ellul claims, actually hindered the progress of technique.
Christians were opposed to the worldly values of money and power and instead
directed themselves towards the eschatological City of God. Because the world
was considered officially Christian until the fourteenth century, little
technical progress was made during this time. “When an element of technique
appeared to be righteous from every point of view, it was adopted, but even
then with excessive caution” (Ellul 37). Public society had theological reasons
to check the progression of technique.
It was not
until the Industrial Revolution in the eighteenth century that technique took
on its modern characteristics. By then all the necessary aspects of society
were in place for a technical revolution. Ellul analyzes the five social
conditions needed to produce modern technique: history had freed technique to
mature without checks, the population had grown substantially, economies
prospered, transportation allowed people to travel freely and society valued
technical results. All five of these aspects together gave rise to the new
nature of technique that we encounter today.
Ellul's issue was not with technological machines but with a society
necessarily caught up in efficient methodological techniques. Technology, then,
is but an expression and by-product of the underlying reliance on technique, on
the proceduralization whereby everything is organized and managed to function
most efficiently, and directed toward the most expedient end of the highest
productivity. Ellul's own comprehensive definition is found in the preface of The Technological Society:
"Technique is the totality of methods, rationally arrived at and having
absolute efficiency (for a given stage of development) in every field of human
activity."
For Ellul
Technology
that is supposed to serve human beings has become a dominant necessity taking
away the freedom and thus enslaved human beings through the structure of means
to achieve efficiency.
Technology
and its culture come into contradiction with the values of the gospel because
Gospel is to announce freedom. Gospel can become counter cultural. We do not
need to take the culture created by networking and technology without being
critical because it has been created as necessity rather than to enable human
beings to exercise freedom.
Technique is
more than technology – a system and structure guided by the means and
principles. Ellul clearly attacks human centred progress perspectives which are
well structured around the techniques that human beings organised.
These
techniques also eliminate or ignore some qualities of human beings in terms of
freedom of communication such as word into visual culture. In his book
Humiliation of the word, Language is
further humiliated by intellectuals, especially certain structuralists, whose
attacks on language that communicates meaning and whose preference for the
"pure" language of the insane appear to have triggered the writing of
this book.
Most of us
now think essentially by association of images, Ellul believes, and can no
longer construct or follow a rigorous logical demonstration, unless this is
supported by charts and diagrams. As schools increase their reliance on images,
educational levels decrease, indicating that images are not the panacea we
presume them to be.
In
theological terms, God’s choice of language as the basis of his contact with
humanity signifies that we are free to respond -- or to ignore him if we
choose. Reliance on images eliminates the freedom that is essential to us if we
are to respond to God.
By opting
for images the technology slowly rejects
and thus humiliates word. If I
extend Ellul today, the convergent language (visual- aural and typed) has
replaced all other types of communication.
Thus human beings inevitably depend on the language and technology of
today and enslaved them.
Mission Shaped Technology
Mission is multifaced. It is essential to proclaim the good
news in all formats and through all means available to us. Mission is also to
affirm life of all beings, particularly life of human beings. Today more than
ever people used technology not merely to help victims but to send the video
clips of murder or killing through video clips. This betrays the human charity
and resistance to any killing has been replaced by who will be the first one to
show this death or murder to the world and how many clicks one gets. Mission is
also to reaffirm and nourish human relationship within the family and within
the community in just and peaceful ways. Technology tends to replace this human
relationship very often that many of us have become dependent on them and
inevitable became a replacement of social communication even within the family.
Gospel is counter cultural because it rejects anything that
takes away the human life. Gospel is counter cultural because it demands
everyone to love one’s neighbour and God and thus give time to each other
rather love only through messages, texts and video clips.
Technique – rationality, human self centred, progress,
totalitarian society, utilitarian,
How concretely this
mission works?
I am a critique of Ellul as well in the sense while being
countercultural we can only bring awareness and education among the public and
ask them to discover new ways of maintaining some good methods and models of
communication that existed before without asking people to reject or ignore the
technology altogether. Of course Ellul
too does not suggest this rather discovering God in the old ways of
narrativity, language, word, orality, natural sound and presence rather than a
technological articulation of all of them.
First we recognise the importance of communication – which
means an action in common – I often call it as communi-action. This cannot be equated to mere information.
Language, narrative, story telling, relationship and presence all exist in communication
including information. The modern technology attempts to enhance interactivity
and participation and so we need to find the ways to synergise both good
characteristics. But without being critically aware of technology and the
culture that it has created such characteristics disappear.
I find a bit of commonality between Newbigin and Ellul, both
questioning the modernity and rationality while Ellul is particularly
questioning the claims around techniques and technology and in particular
questioning the enslavement of human beings by the use of technology itself
which is supposed to serve them.
Eucharist is an
ideal space where presence and communal action together are essential part of
being one in Christ – it is a place where we remind ourselves that we are part
of the body of Christ. Mutually
interrelated and mutually interdependent but mutually are different as well. Here all the individuals are affirmed and are
connected into one body of Christ. In this sense everyone’s freedom,
participation and interactivity are important. So communication is more than
just information in this context.
Trinity is
communitarian where spectator becomes spec-actor – giver and receiver. There is
a freedom for each in three into which we are called to participate. This is an
ideal space where we are invited to engage and take part in.
Church is the Bride
of Christ in which relationship is the prime importance. The family
relationship cannot be replaced by technology nor reduce it. So the real
presence and relational factors are more important than a mediatory space only.
I myself use a dialectic approach in the attitude towards
the use of technology for mission. We critically engage and identify the crisis
but then we have to face and challenge the dominance but we cannot avoid using
the technology. But with the awareness a different kind of space where freedom
is more expressed and enhanced and through such spaces many others become aware
of such technological constraints and thus creatively recognise the need for
values of the Kingdom of God.
Coming back to my the Crisis
Today we are
dominated by technological necessity. Families are struggling with the
relationship due to gadgets that mediate or even replace the relationship. In
this sense are we technologically literate? Are we aware that technology
creates worldviews, morality and attitude that are at times against the values
of the gospel which are grace, love, mercy, generosity and so on. So my thesis
is to promote Biblical Literacy is essential to counter technological
domination and human enslavement. Biblical literacy can liberate human beings
from this enslavement by reminding those values that are forgotten. In this
sense Biblical literacy and technological awareness can go together in using
and engaging with the technology. Technological literacy can help people to
understand and remove the ignorance and Biblical literacy can enable people to
engage proactively with counter values.
Church can
create alternative spaces where people can realize and participate in this
freedom rather than fall into necessity. This is life affirming, relational and
faith centred approach can enable people to change their mindset and thus use
technology creatively and critically understand techniques and thus challenge
them at various levels. Such spaces can also create awareness about
others’ basic needs and thus engage by helping each other in a shrinking world
that is also witnessing Christ in new ways.
This can be possible by creating a critical and appreciative
space for mission to shape technology. And also by creating a creative and
alternative space for mission to use technology and byreating an access and
networks for mission to be present in technology